The Art of Imperfection

I love to create. I am fast and easy when it comes to writing poetry. I walk while words and images come into my head with the rhythm of my steps. Creating artwork is harder. I used to collage, paint, and mess about with abandon. I want whatever I make to look perfect, or at least close to what I am seeing in my mind.

In my classroom, I encourage my students to collage, paint, build, and mess about, but now I’ve lost that childlike wonder. I tell children that the imperfect is more perfect than the perfect, borrowing from Ruskin. However, I think deep down inside I don’t believe that. I want to make things that are pretty, that are recognizable, that are accepted by the public. I know this is backward, unproductive thinking, but I haven’t been able to shake it for some time now.

This morning, I woke up and did ALL the items on my school “to do” list. I am very, very good at school. I can check off school. Art is different. I can’t just check off art. I have to feel it. I have to be willing and brave enough to make a mistake. I have to be willing to see that mistake as beautiful. I don’t know when I became so guarded. I used to paint so wildly that I’d get paint in my hair, on my face, and splattered on some favorite nearby object. I have become too careful in my old age. “Hold on, don’t fail.” “Maybe you shouldn’t eat that.” “When’s my next doctor’s appointment?” My inner artist wants to run free, screaming with abandon.

And so, this morning I took out my watercolors once again. I told myself it’s okay if it’s blotchy. It’s okay if the colors bleed into each other. It’s okay to make a mess. But honestly, I cheated. To get me going again, I cheated. I bought a watercolor workbook from Emily Lex Studio. This workbook is filled with light images of flower bouquets and gives you a color palette and step-by-step instructions. Ordinarily, this type of workbook would not interest me one bit. But I thought it would be an important bridge to overcome my addiction to perfection. I might get over my painting phobia and begin to create again with childlike abandon. One can only hope. I am not getting any younger!

Finally, I sat down, dipped my brush in water, and followed each step. The colors were not exactly like the ones on the suggested palette. It was okay with me. I could let that go. My brushstrokes were much more unsteady than they were when I was younger. It was okay with me. I can let go and make it more Impressionistic. I was too heavy-handed with my lines. I held my brush too tight. I didn’t want to let go. That was okay with me. Over time, I would learn to let go again. The important thing was that I made an imperfect striped jug of imperfect pink peonies. Brava!

Looking at those peonies drying on my table, I realize Ruskin was right after all. There is a quiet grace in the wobble of an unsteady hand and the surprise of colors bleeding where they weren’t invited. Something inside me loosened its grip just a little bit. The workbook still has plenty of pages left, and next time, I might even try coloring outside the lines in my own color palette.

What is one creative habit you’ve put on hold because you’re afraid it won’t be “Perfect”?

Leave a Reply